Both are horrible, no doubt about that, but for me the worst scenario would be not to be able to buy used games.For the current gen I haven't bought a single used game, but that's because I went with pc gaming. I'm now planning on getting a PS5 next year, and there's a list of ps4 games that I really want to get, so the used market will look very attractive. Regarding the 'always online', it wouldn't affect me that much since I don't usually have internet outages (otherwise I would be really screwed since I'm working from home), and in case of an outage I could easily hotspot my mobile connection, however, I understand how this would be a huge problem for many people, so I'm really glad neither have been implemented.