Okay, let's try to be as objective as possible here.
None of them showed much gameplay so that is a negative point for both. Also, many of the games shown in both presentations appeared to be 2021 and 2022 releases so...
But these are the games that I liked on each show:
| Sony Horizon2 Spiderman Demon's Soul Remaster. Kena Project Athia R&C GT7 Hitman Astrobot Little Devil Inside REVIIlage |
Microsoft Fable Avowed CrossFireX Stalker2 Halo Everwild The Medium Warhammer 40,000 Grounded The Gunk Forza |
I would call it a tie, but the fact that all of MS's games will be on Gamepass is a huge deal, so I will give the edge to Microsoft here.







