By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Jaicee said:
DarkD said:

Nonsense.  A lot of people played a few hours, were so put off by a storyline decision that they dropped the game right there and reviewed it.  Some people read the spoilers and were put off from that as well.  I would say either is fair game.

I see. So what you're saying is that thousands of people picked this game up the second it was released at midnight Eastern Time on Friday morning, took it home, played it for two hours, and then, disgusted, turned the game off and wrote negative reviews...and then went back in time two and a half hours to post them at 12:02 AM?

No dude, the vast majority of the "reviews" we've seen over on MC to date are obviously written by people who don't own the game, never intended to, and had in fact made up their minds in that regard years ago, not a day or two ago.

The fact is that even now, few people will realistically have completed the game, as such a feat would have required around 12 hours of play for two days, the average gamer typically averaging not more than a few hours a day of video gaming. In other words, average players of this game won't likely be posting user reviews of it until like after next weekend at the earliest, although perhaps a very small number of exceedingly dedicated people who don't have lives may have in fact completed TLOU2 by now. And you can't help but notice that, as time goes on, the share of TLOU2 reviews that are positive is slowly increasing. There will likely never be enough objective reviews to overcome what legions of trolls have already done to the average "user" score, but expect the percentage of reviews that are positive to keep increasing over time as more and more people actually complete the game.

I say that the share of Metacritic users scoring TLOU2 positively will continue to increase over time as more people actually complete the game with confidence because I'm now many hours into it myself and have a tentatively very positive opinion of the game as yet. And it's mainly because of the game's narrative, not in spite of it. It's much too early to reveal important plot details right now, but after I complete the game and have had time to absorb it, I intend to author a thread with my personal thoughts and feelings because, while I mean no, this game isn't going to resonate the same way for everybody (I get that very clearly), my experience so far is filling me with all kinds of strong emotions on subjects that are deeply personal to me. I really want to share.

Once again, your points don't make sense.  Everyone knows there's bias going on.  And there's plenty of people like yourself no doubt giving it 10/10 stars simply to "make up for the 1-stars".  Given how personally you've taken it, I would bet you've already reviewed it yourself.  One look should tell you to look for a third source if you wanna accurately score it.  Personally I took the "IGN Japan" score as more accurate since Japan doesn't have the same political biases. 

As for user scores, I listened to a streamer who's determined to play the game the whole way through.  I've watched him play a few sections on the hardest difficulty.  He says 70/100 as well and he also says 80/100 for TLOU Part 1.  

If anything, I welcome the scores on both sides since they make it obvious the system is completely corrupt and people should be more discerning.  Just like Fox News lies all the time, CNN lies all the time.  People should research things a bit more carefully.