| Soundwave said: There's no rule that says MS can't have their 52 CUs run at a higher clock ... it's probably doable quite frankly. If they do that, then the gap that already exists will grow higher. If anything I think the SSD speed stuff is overrated ... the XSX already has a very fast NVMe SSD, the hardware with the better chip pretty much always over time shows itself to be superior. Sony knew I think MS wasn't going to let them have the better hardware again, if they went to 52 CUs, then MS simply would have spent more and so on and so on, so knowing they were beat on that front they've chosen to play up this SSD angle because it's all they got hardware wise to point to. MS learned their lesson with XBox One and weren't going to allow Sony to have a more powerful console ever again. XBox One X being better than the PS4 Pro was a tip off. MS leans more on multiplats, and multiplats that look/play best on their console is something they need. MS has deeper pockets than Sony, Sony fans may as well forget about having better hardware, MS learned from this gen that they can't have weaker hardware and can simply outspend Sony on hardware. |
The funny thing is, Microsoft Xbox Division hyping the same thing with the SSD. They understand the important of SSD and they know SSD will be the next big thing and changed the future of graphic.
Xbox SX has Nvme SSD, but Sony went Super Saiyan 4 with the SS/ IO and Xbox SX went Super Saiyan 2 with the SSD. I am not saying Xbox SX weak in terms of SSD, but in terms of SSD and IO i think Sony is just another level (according to the paper spec and developer ) . XBox has advantage on Compute unite over PS5, but not much and also has advantage slightly on overall raw GPU power but around 17 % to 18 %.
Microsoft focusing on "raw power" by adding more CU but at the same time sacrificing the IO costume (less customizable component) on the APU, While Sony focusing on developer request on SSD and bottle neck (costume IO) by doing that Sony sacrificing compute unit on PS5, (they have less CU on the GPU)
If you asked me “why Microsoft focus power not SSD?". As we know Microsoft current gen Xbox One were known as weak consoles, they want to change that image and already did with Xbox One X. They want to keep the momentum to XBOX SX, bringing the same flag and motto “the most powerful " console.
They knew SSD is the most important factor, but at the same time they don’t want to lose their fans who proud with “Power" is everything. They don't want to lose their fans again, even if in the end it will not giving a real benefit for game development in the future. At least they get the marketing angle.
Sony is different, from the beginning of PS4 development, they trying to please developer, they learning from their past mistake with PS3, they motto is always asked the developer first what is their idea and input. The reason why PS4 are powerful it's just a matter of coincident, Xbox one has bigger die then PS4 APU. But their focus on media and Kinect that lead to utilization of SRAM inside the APU and a waste of die space, that’s the one that killed the performance.
Sony from the beginning of this generation always "asked developer first”. It always is since PS4 and now with PS5.
They don’t care about what layman like us want, they don’t care about teraflop, they design system that will result great for gamers and developer.
Microsoft it’s a bit of mixed bag, in one side developer requested but in the other side they afraid of losing their core audience with "power" and more "power". there is nothing bad with power but sometimes they don't have to listen everything from the consumer.
In the end both machine are capable, 12 teraflop with 52 CU are good in raw performance and handling traditional way on rendering games, but games like the one running on UE 5, will be difficult for Xbox and Xbox will not have performance advantage over PS5. And quite possibly PS5 will have advantage over Xbox SX in this area.
But for games build on traditional way i think Xbox SX will have slightly advantage , altho only slightly.
Last edited by HollyGamer - on 08 June 2020
