Eh, beyond the fact that no game is truly photoreal (and developers are actually not chasing that), claiming that the more realistic style visuals don't hold up just isn't true. Plenty of games from the 360/PS3 era hold up nicely today, and as graphics get even better, that will continue to be the case. Games that are more stylized also hold up well, but both can be true without trampling the craft of one of them.
Any examples, because I cant think of a single ps360 game with realistic graphics that looks good now. The last of us is considered one of the best looking games of that gen and it's pretty ugly now.