What are your fave RPG ever?

[Jabba89]

HoloDust said:

John2290 said:
Some people don't count the withcer 3 as an RPG and I'm sometimes inclined to agree but thst being my favourite game I've ever played I should mention it cause it does resemble an RPG in many ways just without the role playing. If it's not counted I'd have to decide between Divinity OS and Divinity OS2 and I wouldn't be able to make the vhoice, I like them both to such a high level for differing reasons around the edges but Divinity OS's more focused and confined experience would be on of the majour weights to my decision, The openish ended map with no clear distinction in levels until you are lovked into a half hour fight, in DOS2 feels just a little off.

I've seen this opionion many times, personally I find TW3 to be a borderline case with just enough elements not to transition fully into pseudo RPGs like Horizon and AC:O, thought it certainly provided template for such.

These games definitely are RPGs, I think the problem is that when someone used to say RPG it was taken to mean JRPG.  Given that the RPG genre has evolved and has a lot of subgenres it may have been better to be a little more specific so we were comparing apples with apples.

I don't find much value in comparing The Witcher 3 with Final Fantasy VII with Fallout 3.