DonFerrari said:
Azzanation said:
Holly, the point isn't hard to grasp. Fan made or not, the fact its Mario not on a Nintendo device or without Nintendo's consent affects the IPs quality in itself and profits Sony and not Nintendo since Dreams is only on PS4. If Sony want content like that to be there without any issues than maybe Sony should release Dreams on the Switch, than Nintendo might let it go. Fan made content will help sell Dreams and PS4s not Nintendo Switches, that's the bottom line and that's why Nintendo want to take this stuff down. Want Mario? buy a Switch, there is a perfectly good Mario game out there in Mario Odyssey.
I agree on Nintendo taking full control on there IP's reputations and id expect Sony to do the exact same if Nintendo had a content creating tool using IPs from Sony. This is why Nintendo have the most valuable IPs in the entire industry, Nintendo don't let them get washed out by others.
|
Still you would need to prove the sales that were made because people wanted to play Mario games on PS4.
Second you would need to prove that dreams have a "content creating tool using IP" from Nintendo. Because it doesn't, people can create whatever they want with the tool, but there isn't any Nintendo IP on the tool, if there was they could ask for sanction against sony itself.
Third this type of situation would most likely fall under fair use as it is fan made content not for profit and not copying the content but recreating it.
|
If this fan game is legal, Sony won't have to accept Nin's request, but they know it's wrong.
HollyGamer said:
HoangNhatAnh said:
What's false? Explain it.
So you said i defended Nin without attacking Sony was wrong, but you attacked someone to defend another is fine? A fan made game about Nintendo character on ps4? No different than Metroid AM2R on pc which got taken down by Nin. If it is on Nin system only, it may work, but not this.
|
I never attacking anyone LOL, I am just not agree with Nintendo Policy. If you feel attacked by me and try to changing the subject to fan war there is something wrong with u. I am just cleary tell you to stop defending every bad policy on Nintendo.
|
You attacked Xenoblade before when people criticized Square Enix because Final Fantasy XIII.
