But since Metacritic has more reviews, and RDR2 is above BotW and Mario Odyssey according to Metacritic, it makes RDR2 universally the better game. The score-difference between these games in Gamerankings is also only a couple decimals (0,3-0, 4) so it's not enough to compensate.
Everyone of course has his own opinion, but facts are facts.
It's been some time, but I feel this post is relevant so pardon the necro.
Seems new data from Metacritic came out:
Since you were in the decimal game, here's from the people you relied on themselves.