Well, I mean the 360 was just plain bad but for the rest. I did not have any problem.
At least nothing abnormal or more than any other console and I do not think the Xbox One can be considerate as not reliable; esp. compared to the 2 other big ones (Sony and Nintendo consoles).
For me it look like that:
- One of my Xbox One controller shoulder went dead on my elite controller.
- I had to replace one of my Playstation Four controller (completely stopped working and could not even recharge) and I switched for a non Sony controller (not because of the quality but for the layout, I like the Xbox/Switch layout better).
- And basically all of my Switch joycons... (which was like 8 of them and even today, some of the new ones are already drifting like crazy)