shikamaru317 said:
Sounds like a decision by the showrunners then, to portray Daenerys increasingly darker throughout the series, while they chose to portray Jon Snow as the good guy choice to rule in the end. I can see why that would make fans of the books angry, but I've never read the books, so all I have to go on is the show. And speaking solely from a show watchers perspective, I have definitely favored Jon since the start of the show, because with the exception of the hanging of the people that stabbed him to death, he was always shown to be merciful, the good guy of the series just like his uncle Ned Stark. Dany always seemed to have a hint of her fathers madness lying just beneath the surface, to me at least. You can see it in both her mannerisms and in her decisions. It was abundantly obvious to me, as someone who binge-watched the entire show for the first time over the last month. |
By GRRM's own admission, he started to tell the showrunners future plot points of the series, not covered by the books, around 2013 - 2014, after at least three or four TV seasons or so were filmed. Now, we don't know whether that early talk includes the ending or that was revealed in later conversations. But it already rules out the suggestion there's something more sinister hidden on her mannerisms and decisions in earlier seasons.
Not to mention we now know all the health issues Emilia Clarke was facing as she filmed the TV show, so all this talk about strange twiches etc. on her character just get a much more sad and mean connotation.
Edit: GRRM might have some portion of blame. He's a "gardener" who tries to evolve his characters and plots organically. It takes a lot of time to do but doesn't incur the risk of making characters seem automatons guiding the plot to a certain conclusion. But as the show caught up with his books, he might have found himself having to share future plot points he conceived years or decades ago, before his own storytelling pulled him on another direction. Now it remains to be seen how he'll write those books, since I don't think he has the luxury of scraping plot points that won't work, now that they're effectively pinned by the TV show. I mean, he has, but likely wouldn't do it.
Last edited by haxxiy - on 12 May 2019
