By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
DonFerrari said:
HoangNhatAnh said:

If you ask me, Phantasy Star II and IV are the best RPGs to me, league ahead any RPG i have played so far including Xeno games and Fire Emblem series. Sure, i'm a Nintendo fan, but depends on what kind of game, i can agree or not, and definitely not some cinematic with QTEs games. "these 2 games better than any year in gaming on 40 years of history isn't something I would agree", of course they aren't, but if we compare them to GOW, Spider Man and Detroit, a lot people think they are better outside Sony fans and graphic fans

I have no problem with either you not liking GoW (Which won GOTY), SM and Detroit or thinking they aren't better than Odissey and BotW, but those were just 3 of the games on 2018. GoW even if fantastic and having a lot of gameplay and story besides graphics, SM being pretty fun and gameplay heavy, Detroit with a deep story are more than just graphics (although those are the most impressive features on then) are certainly not for everyone and surely sold less than Odissey and BotW plus review score is lower but neither are definite measures of what is better.

He didn't said that no publisher made 2 games on the same year better than Odissey and BotW nor something of the like. He put all games launched in the year on another platform.

If I asked you if you would ask you (as usually people like to go to these extremes), would you rather play these 2 games for the rest of your life or chose all the games on a console launched in any specific year of your choosing. Which year and platform would you chose?

A bit hyperbole and poor wording. I also don't agree with him that "no publisher made 2 games on the same year better than Odyssey and BotW nor something of the like" but will agree with something like this: "best launch console with 1st party game ever". "Would you rather play these 2 games for the rest of your life or chose all the games on a console launched in any specific year of your choosing. Which year and platform would you chose?" Of course i will choose launch games for a console, but i'm not interest in Odyssey, i would pick FE Warriors, Xenoblade 2, Mario X Rabbids and Arms over it. However, i don't think majority people outside Sony fans and graphic whores will agree with you that those 3 games are better than Odyssey and BOTW including neutral fans