People that selected RD2 over GOW to win goty most likely a R* fanboy and not really into games that much.
Interesting generalization coming from someone with a Kratos avatar. You're talking about two amazing games, literally the two best games released this year by pretty much every metric. Maybe people just enjoyed Red Dead more?
How in the world is RDR2 a game for people "not into games that much" lol. It's one of the most video gamey video games I've ever played. Everything has levels and progress bars and their own systems to manage.