RDR2 Reviews! Metacritic - 97(PS4)/97(XBO) / Opencritic - 97

[WhatATimeToBeAlive]

OTBWY said:

WhatATimeToBeAlive said:

Of course, but those numbers are the closest thing to objectivity in this case.

No they aren't. Cause if we are being objective, you would have to deny that the Xbox One version is the superior version. Yet, it's below RDR2 for PS4. So that in itself makes it nonsense, since the Xbox One version is clearly without question the best version. Also in this exact same convo, when we take the MC decimals, you would have to accept that Super Mario Galaxy is objectively a superior game. Do you see how stupid it is going to get?

This right here is nothing but opinion. Subjective. All of it.

Well, it was you who brought up the fact that BotW has few decimals higher score than RDR2 in Gamerankings. Why did you do it if you think it's meaningless?

 

I can accept the fact that Super Mario Galaxy is rated higher than RDR2 in Metacritic, and thus is objectively a superior game. Atleast it's more objective than individual opinions. Although, those games have been released several years apart, so it's not as relevant to compare games that are from different eras.