Trump Plans to Challenge the Constitutional Definition of Birthright Citizenship

[Wyrdness]

melbye said:

Wyrdness said:

They're not born in their parents country though as things go the new born only has connections to the place they're born that's the whole point, other countries for example aren't going to hand out citizenship by default just because your dad was from there otherwise half the world would be duo citizens.

The other flaw is going by what you're saying here only Mexicans (ironically) and Native Americans should be US citizens because the rest of America had ancestry born outside of the country meaning most of them are British, Spanish and French citizens as they'd all have to be EU citizens because that's who their ancestors belonged to under your view.

No offense, but i feel like you are misunderstanding what i am saying on purpose and i really don't have the energy for this right now, Have a nice day or night dependingon where you live

No it's just your point of view has contradictions which you've not really addressed I'm not the only to say this either which highlights this.