| ZenfoldorVGI said:
I'm not trying to keep a flame post going, so I'll try not to offend with my responses here. In my opinion, both Uncharted and Gears are mildly over-rated. Neither game has any above average art-style. I'd say they are incomparable. I also believe that anyone who says Uncharted looks better obviously owns a PS3, take that to mean what you will. I'm not here to argue over opinion. I assert that you are probably simply a Sony fan trying to push the PS3's graphical power by pushing your "PS3 exclusives look better" talking point, but lets not kid ourselves, I can't prove it, but everyone knows it obvious, as are many things obvious on these forums that we might feel aren't quite politically correct, so we might not say them. A flame war, which is going on right now, is ugly and rude and doesn't belong on this forum.
FYI, however, I own a PS3 and a 360, I don't own a Wii, and don't think I brought up anything about Nintendo. The two systems are virtually identical graphic-wise, and anyone who takes one systems side over another probaby has alterior fanboy motives. The proper, unbiased answer to Uncharted vs Gears is "I don't know." Still, since Gears has been out far longer, has more fans, and more people have seen it, there is no doubt that the vast majority of internet graphics whores have touted Gears far more than Uncharted. I say we end it right here. I'm not gonna respond again, because I don't wanna get in a fight on these forums and risk moderation when in reality nobody but you and I even care about this argument. It's silly, pointless, and laden with "gotcha moments" used to hide what everyone knows, which is that we are both slightly biased towards which console, for whatever reason, we feel is the best. In your case the PS3, in my case the Wii. |
Didn't you have a Wii and traded it for a 360 because it was a straight up trade? Therefore you got a 360 for $250, but at the same time you are in the process of getting another Wii? Anyways, and no offense, but to me when someone says I have Console X and Y but Console X is blah blah blah is the same as when someone says I have friends of Race X so I'm not racist but Race X is blah blah blah.
I disagree when you say that all graphics whore will say Gears look better than Uncharted, all graphics whore I've seen on forums have said the other way around and again I've played both games on a 1080p capable TV and I think that Uncharted looks superior to Gears even though Gears is a better game. I personally think they both deserver they hype and rate Uncharted 92 and GOW 95. I can't speak for other Sony fans but I'd much rather have Gears 2 than Uncharted 2. I also think there are a lot of garbage PS3 exclusives and most 3rd party exclusives look better on the 360 (But at least lately they've been similar). I'll agree with you that neither console really holds that big of a graphical advantage over the other, or at least I haven't seen any great leaps out of any games that are out right now and I've always said that up until now the 360 has the best games library out of all current gen consoles.
Everybody has their little bias, it's human nature and that's ok, what makes it bad is when someone goes to extremes and start becoming blind to reasoning and facts. I'm partial to Sony after being partial to Nintendo until this generation, I just feel the Wii is not for me even though I'll have to buy one for my gf as her birthday gift.
With all that said, let us have peace:
