Should NS and wiiU be both labeled as 8th generation?

[Wyrdness]

JRPGfan said:

Wyrdness said:

I group NS as a 9th gen because it succeeds an 8th gen platform as a new platform, nothing complicated about it.

Then I name the PS4pro & XB1X as 9th gen too... and PS5/XB2 will be the 10th gen!
It doesnt make sense just cus you say something.

A gen can have more than 1 console in it, Nintendo Wii U time was just so short, they had 2 consoles in their 8th gen.

You're just being silly now those aren't stand alone new platforms they're different models otherwise by your logic here PS2 Slim was new platform.