By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Homeroids said:

They need a send off rule. Better still, a send off rule that also does not allow another player on so the team needs to play one down. Soccer does that. Even Rugby League has a "sin" bin where the team is one down. Ice Hockey does it for any penalty I thought.


If a dude smacks out another player, breaks their teeth well heck, why is that guy still on the field? just not right. AFL administration are a bunch of idiots.

 The Afl has argued that since the  crackdown on striking these cases that were prevalent twenty years or more ago are now rare, and  if a red card was with the Gaff case how do you police it, in this case you have no umpires report to go by because the behind play nature of it meant they didn't see it  at the time it happened ,my thoughts are keep it how it is unless there  is an upsurge in coward punches  but I admit I wouldn't oppose it if it was introduced strictly for these Barry Hall Andrew Gaff type hits where there is concrete video evidence , but not like amateur football with it's broader criteria.

What I would  like to see is the AFl come out and state that their crackdown on jump punch's and strikes to the body  by making them finable offences is now done and it's suspension from now on, Like Andrew Gaff himself said when asked about his defences proposition that he meant to hit Brayshaw in the chest like  he had done earlier and miscued when Brayshaw propped and lowered his body weight  gaff's reply was it didn't matter  the impact itself was what matters.

Last edited by mjk45 - on 08 August 2018