I think most everyone agrees that Resistance shouldn't be on the list. I agree with replacing it with R&C since it is a shooterish platformer (although I don't think it did the shooting very well).
Some think that GT5 shouldn't be on the list because of Forza. I agree it should be there because Forza and GT5 are different levels of sim racing. The GT series has always be a bit more arcade and focusing on realistic looking cars and environments. Forza is more sim and less forgiving. This leaves room for different types of players. I think this goes the reverse also. I think PS3 fanboys would appreciate Forza more if it was multi-platform. Personally, I like both so I'll be buying GT5 and Forza 3 whenever it comes out.
I give this thread a 9.6.
Thank god for the disable signatures option.
