rocketpig said:
kingofwale said:
makingmusic476 said:
tombi123 said:
Soriku said:
makingmusic476 said:
Lord of the Rings Extended Editions!
I'd die if those were announced. Of course, they would do absolutely nothing for sales. |
Watching 6 hour long movies = DO NOT WANT.
|
All 'book to movie' movies should be about 6 hours long. LotR Extended Edition is much better than the normal LotR. If the Harry Potter movies were 6 hours long, they might have a chance at not sucking.
|
The first two HP movies did their jobs well. Why the shortest books are the longest movies of the series makes no sense to me.
Seriously, HP 4-7 are all almost twice as long as the each LotR novel, yet the movies are half as long. They left out SO much. Everyone I know who's seen the movies but hasn't read the books has no idea what the hell is going in any after 3.
|
Because Harry Potter books are terrible adaptation of JKR's books? We are talking about a bunch of C- actors directed by D+ directors.
Don't get me wrong, I love Harry Potter books, I would go as far as call myself a fan, but the movies themselves are just an embarrassment.
|
Are you really calling Alfonso Cuaron a "D+" director?
The guy directed the movie of the decade IMO.
|
The Prisoner of Azkaban is easily my favorite of the HP films.
