By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
tombi123 said:
Soriku said:
makingmusic476 said:
Lord of the Rings Extended Editions!

I'd die if those were announced. Of course, they would do absolutely nothing for sales.


Watching 6 hour long movies = DO NOT WANT.

 

All 'book to movie' movies should be about 6 hours long. LotR Extended Edition is much better than the normal LotR. If the Harry Potter movies were 6 hours long, they might have a chance at not sucking.

 

The first two HP movies did their jobs well.  Why the shortest books are the longest movies of the series makes no sense to me.

Seriously, HP 4-7 are all almost twice as long as the each LotR novel, yet the movies are half as long.  They left out SO much.  Everyone I know who's seen the movies but hasn't read the books has no idea what the hell is going in any after 3.