Detroit: Become Human Reviews: 79 Metacritic, 80 OpenCritic

[DonFerrari]

Mcube said:

DonFerrari said:

Have you seem the justification for their 4s? Have you seem one of them giving a 90 for a very bare game?

I looked them over. Videogamers review is acceptable and they are a review website I myself use sometimes to check what they think about games. Staff there has changed alot but I dont see anything wrong with what they write. They dont like the tone of the game and states that suerpmassive games with Untill Dawn and Telltale games both make better narrative driven experiences. I agree with him on that I dont think Quantic Dream is the best in Narrative driven games. I enjoyed Untill Dawn and TWD Season 1 more then I enjoy all of quanic dreams games. The other guy is annoyed that the controls are just as annoying as in Heavy Rain which is a complaint that would heavily downgrade the score. They also dont seem to enjoy the story at all. These arent troll reviews these are reviews by people that didnt enjoy this game as much as others in the genre and thought it was below standard for them. BTW the reviewer of Digitallydownloaded rated both Heavy rain and Beyond two souls a perfect score of 5/5 so they dont just ´hate david cage´s games´ they dont like this game. These arent troll reviews. 

I would hate to see you wrong...

Digitallydownloaded

B2S was reviewed by Brad L., HR by Matt S. and Detroit by Tyler T. so none were reviewed by the same reviewer, just on the same publication. And if they were all reviewed by the same person then the score would make even less sense since you would have a hard time to say on one hand that B2S and HR are 100 but Detroit is 40.

They gave 100 for No Man Sky, to Toren, Azures Night, Yonder, Pokemon Go (a lot of gameplay, graphics and history here right?), and several other very bad games...

I find it hard to see any consistency that would allow the 40 score to be objectively fair on their part.

And if you have Videogamers as standard bad as well... 007 Quantum Solace is a 90 for a 65 game... with the only other green game they gave a 40 being Fifa 14 (the iOS version), SSFII HF.

They also gave a 40 for B2S and 90 for HR, so no consistency at all since the games didn't vary as much in quality.