This game was Microsoft’s The Order. Lots of potential but ultimately terribly boring and flawed. The main character was so shallow that I can’t even remember his name and the little game there was was interrupted by very mediocre life action scenes. Anyone who calls this “maybe his best game this gen” must either not have played many games, or deserves to be patronised from now on.
And yet I own all the consoles and have played lots of games this gen. Hope that helps.
Feel free to patronize because someone has a different taste in games than you :)