Well both for me are GotY for their respective years. My personal hype for Zelda was on a much higher level for God of War. It did not diappoint me in the least.
GoW I did not honestly get hyped for until the review scores came in. Until then, I was like "meh". Once I dug into the game a bit after that though, I knew it was a day one buy for me. It also does not disappoint.
That said, considering I was hyped for Zelda to the point that I replayed EVERY canon mainline Zelda game ever released over the course of a year and a half in preparation of BotW, I say Zelda takes the win for me. As for why you do not hear much about Zelda now that GoW was is out, well it was released over a year ago. It really is not rocket science.
Last edited by Shiken - on 29 April 2018