God of War review thread - Meta: 94 OC: 95

[DonFerrari]

xl-klaudkil said:

Manlytears said:

Played BOTW, great game, but overrated as #@$#@. Sure, it's a 9.0 game, but not a 9.7. Not a true game changer, not a revolutionary and innovative gameplay or never seen before experience.... just a good game worth a 9.0 at best.

I highly agree,game whas amazing but not that incredible, there where many issues i had a problem with,and other games would be burried under that!

Yep... I found funny that some reviewers listed a lot of shortcomings and issues, but gave a 100, didn't even take a single point "because I had fun".

loy310 said:

Manlytears said:

Played BOTW, great game, but overrated as #@$#@. Sure, it's a 9.0 game, but not a 9.7. Not a true game changer, not a revolutionary and innovative gameplay or never seen before experience.... just a good game worth a 9.0 at best.

Uncharted 4 was also overrated imho, hell TLoU was also overrated to me. Both games have the most bland generic gameplay. Lost Legacy to me was the best Uncharted in terms of gameplay. I just hate when games become too cinematic.

Well I liked both (prefer UC to TLoU)... but I gotta say the open map of LL on chapter 4 was very pretty, fun and meaningful (no roaming pointlessly).

Ka-pi96 said:

DonFerrari said:
From the 90 reviews so far

80 - 5
85 -2
(so let's say 7 scores that could be disregarded because of being so far below the average)
90 -24 (a good amount of great, but not perfect that could be from 1-5 system)

That would actually be the 80s. You can't get a 90 from a 1-5 system, but an 80 would be the 2nd highest you could get from one (ie. 4/5 is an 80 on metacritic).

You are right, my bad. Was to say no "half points".

Nozz-A-La said:

Xbox and Nintendo fanboy reviews are coming in

Well, they obviously are better than professionals for GoW reviews.

BraLoD said:

Azuren said:

Gonna chime in and agree as well. BotW was my 2017 GotY, and is the best thing Nintendo has ever made in my opinion.

 

But I'm gonna have to say it was a solid 9.4, and anything above that (to me) is just fanaticism.

So are you saying my score of 11/10 to LoD is fanaticism? Gonna report you.

Nope, but a 9/10 would be trolling.