Doom graphics comparison Xbox One X vs Switch

[DonFerrari]

LudicrousSpeed said:

Yeah man all things kept the same. So I guess in your hypothetical where two platforms exist at the same price with the same libraries with the same control options using the same UI and online network but one had a 4k output and the other 720p or whatever, plus both were portable, then yeahin that bizarre never going to happen scenario it would make zero sense to pick the 720p version. Unfortunately for your hypothetical, we’re discussing reality.

You may discuss whatever you want, the point was as simple as having better graphics would improve the enjoyment, that is a very ceteris paribus point.

Someone valuing gameplay, portability, price, library, input scheme or whatever is totally fine, but that wasn't the point made.

zorg1000 said:

DonFerrari said:

Not being intentional about anything.

You are reducing the difference to not easily noticeable, while the topic is a 4k Doom on X1X against a sub 900p on Switch (with also a half the fps as well) and not seeing any issue with "better graphics while the rest is kept the same doesn't improve your experience"

The point remains the same, higher resolution does not make a game better, it makes it prettier which for some people is important, for others it doesnt matter.

We havent been talking about performance this entire time so bringing it up now it pointless, i agree that better performance can make a game better if it runs like garbage.

Nobody is claiming it cant improve your experience, we are saying that its not going to for everybody. I can tell you for a fact that i would enjoy a 1080p game on PS4 just as much as the 4K version on XBX if the only diffetence is visuals.

Yes yes sure.