What's the most overrated game ever in your opinion?

[Lucca]

Hirouakan said:

Errorist76 said:

Ridiculous. Not even worth discussing imho. The only game that doesn’t have great gameplay in both series is Uncharted 1.

So you say. I'll repeat: Don't think the gameplay is bad. It does it's job and that's it. I just disagree with the consensus that both series are a masterpiece.

Exactly. The gameplay is good enough, but for a GAME, gameplay is the most important feature, so I wouldn't consider them masterpieces just because of the story. Same case for the Telltale games.