This game does seem to be polarizing. Three of the four early reviews on MC seem positive, but the lack of content is the big complaint I keep seeing. The other review brings this up. Now I just saw this article on IGN:
http://m.ign.com/articles/2018/03/20/sea-of-thieves-players-worried-about-lack-of-cosmetic-items-amount-of-total-content
There seems to be both strong positive and strong negative feedback.







