gamrConnect Presents: Their 1077 Greatest Games - 2017 Edition

[uran10]

Machina said:

uran10 said:

Um Yes, yes there is. Red and blue aren't the best pokemon games, quite frankly I'm happy to see so many pokemon games in the top 50. I'd rather a mystery dungeon game (time/darkness/sky) be there instead of platinum and gen 4, but the others definitely deserve it. Especially GSC, easily the best Pokemon games, easily.

Hence why I said Red/Blue and one of the modern ones. Red/Blue because they were the first, the innovators, and the basis for all of the subsequent entries, and therefore I'd argue the best for their time. And one of the modern entries - whichever is generally considered 'the best' at the time of voting.

If you think 12% of the absolute best games of all time are Pokemon games then at least you're guaranteed a new top 50 game every other year or so, so there's that.

um no. Not all Pokemon games are created equal so that logic doesn't work out if you ask me. Also 18% of my top 50 list is Pokemon so I believe more than 12% of the absolute best games of all time are Pokemon games, but it doesn't mean each game made it in. I don't understand why gen 4 is that high up tbh but that's a different case.