By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
KLAMarine on 16 October 2017
Edit Thread
Mar1217 said:
KLAMarine said:

I'm not saying Destiny was the best game of the 8th gen, all I'm saying is it was the most noteworthy with its release timing and big names backing it: Activision and Bungie, the latter of which had never developed a prominent sci-fi shooter for the PS platform.

GotG is not always a form of praise. For me, Destiny is worthy of the GotG label for how disappointing it was despite its great promise.

ET is potential candidate of being a Game of its Respective Generation because of its impact on the industry at its time. Notorious lack of quality that hurts an industry can make you a GotG..

Mass Effect Andromeda and Watch Dogs confirmed GotG !!

Never played either but I don't think either were as bad as ET.

danasider said:
KLAMarine said:

I'm not saying Destiny was the best game of the 8th gen, all I'm saying is it was the most noteworthy with its release timing and big names backing it: Activision and Bungie, the latter of which had never developed a prominent sci-fi shooter for the PS platform.

GotG is not always a form of praise. For me, Destiny is worthy of the GotG label for how disappointing it was despite its great promise.

ET is potential candidate of being a Game of its Respective Generation because of its impact on the industry at its time. Notorious lack of quality that hurts an industry can make you a GotG.

I don't mean to beat a dead horse, but I am not understanding how you arrived to your definition of Game of the Generation. Typically, that doesn't mean most infamous game or most hyped game. It usually means best or most impactful.

I can see Destiny having a lot of hype due to the people backing it or how it had so much potential. But I am struggling to reconcile those things with reason for a game to get Game of the Generation recognition.

No offense, but it just sounds like you're making that definition up. I guess, technically, YOUR GotG can be any game, because that's a personal pick. I just never heard of the reasons or definition you gave for a game being GotG. Further, could you name another generation where the GotG was a huge disappointment like Destiny? Because I can't think of one.(Edited, because I missed that last sentence. However, ET was never a GotG. Especially after releasing 2 years after Pac Man. I think you are mistaking notorious for generation defining.)

< I don't mean to beat a dead horse, but I am not understanding how you arrived to your definition of Game of the Generation. Typically, that doesn't mean most infamous game or most hyped game. It usually means best or most impactful.

I can see Destiny having a lot of hype due to the people backing it or how it had so much potential. But I am struggling to reconcile those things with reason for a game to get Game of the Generation recognition.

> How good or bad a game is is of little relevance when I consider labeling a game 'Game of the Generation'. I absolutely LOVE Resident Evil 4, played it a million times, but as much as I love it, Halo Combat Evolved beats it out hands down considering Halo established a new platform, XBox, almost singlehandedly. I've never played CoD4 Modern Warfare but it's undeniable all the modern military shooters that released after that title in the 7th gen and its dominance saleswise for a time and setting online gaming trends.

< No offense, but it just sounds like you're making that definition up. I guess, technically, YOUR GotG can be any game, because that's a personal pick. I just never heard of the reasons or definition you gave for a game being GotG. Further, could you name another generation where the GotG was a huge disappointment like Destiny? Because I can't think of one.(Edited, because I missed that last sentence. However, ET was never a GotG. Especially after releasing 2 years after Pac Man. I think you are mistaking notorious for generation defining.)

> lol, I admit I'm throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks. 8th gen is a tough one, I must say, not as easy as previous gens (see http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=214574 ). I can't really think of any one game having the impact CoD4 had years ago or helping to usher in 3d gaming like Super Mario 64 did. I feel 8th gen was filled with lots of disappointment, moreso than previous gens especially considering how poorly it started: only one out of three platforms had major appeal. One of the biggest disappointments of the gen was Destiny.