First time I played Bioshock 2 I ran into the same issues I got when I first played Twilight Princess: I focused so much on similarities with previous games (Ocarina of Time in Twilight Princess' case) that I ended up hurting my own enjoyment with the game.
I finished Twilight Princess and thought it was a good game but not on par with other Zelda games. Bioshock 2 I played for about half an hour, thought to myself that this was just more of the same with some female Big Daddies thrown in, and uninstalled it.
Years later I played Twilight Princess HD, went in with a more open mind and discovered a masterpiece. Bioshock 2 also got another chance and apart from the 'Protect the little sister' segments feeling a bit repetitive and tedious after a while (I don't think you had to do them all though) it was a great experience.
