By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

The Last of Us and Uncharted are decent but not great. Pretty much everything made by Naughty Dog has been overrated since and including Crash Bandicoot (never played Jak and Daxter series, so those games are not included).

Halo is not that good. I used to think it was because of the horrible og XBox controller and my general dislike for dual analog aiming that I couldn't get into the series, but when I got Halo 2 for PC and could use the superior mouse and keyboard controls I found a campaign that wasn't well-designed and vehicles that were more annoying than fun. Multiplayer was pretty good, though.

Every mainline console Zelda since and including Wind Waker has been better than Ocarina and ALTTP. Skyward Sword is the best Zelda and my personal favorite game of all time.

Mass Effect 3 is the best of the series despite its poor ending. The rest of the game was just so good.

Rogue Leader remains the best Star Wars game to date and the best Gamecube game.

Each Smash Bros. game has been better than the last, so Melee is only the third best Smash game.

Sonic has never come close to matching Mario in quality, even in the 16 bit era. Sonics 1-Knuckles are all good, but flawed.