Trump has decided to end DACA

[GhaudePhaede010]

Locknuts said:

TK-Karma said:

Hmm ... it's arguable as to whether the children can really be accused of breaking the rules, though. For one, it's safe to assume that pretty much no child would just leave their parents, because their parents were planning to illegally enter another country for their benefit. Secondly, if in other areas of law, where children are unable to give informed consent on various topics, it's debatable that such logic be extended to this type of situation too. They've just been brought along for the ride. It's a pretty grey area either way :(

The children haven't broken the rules, but they obtained citizenship as proceeds of a crime, which is illegal. The parents have put their children in a horrible situation.

If you steal a car and then give it to your children, they won't be allowed to keep the car. This is provided that GTA was a crime at the time of the theft.

You are correct that they would not get to keep the car but they certainly would not be punished by prison or eviction either. The problem is that there seems to be no middle ground. I understand being harsh towards adults but being that harsh to children, whom we all swear to protect first and foremost, is cruel and insinsitive. There must be a better way.