Well, I have some kind of the same feeling but I am sure that it has to with playing to many games.
I am a RPG fan but this days all the RPG's are getting to look the same with almost never something new...I can remember the day I played for the first time a RPG I didn't understand anything about it at first but I loved it later, it was like magic for me...
Games really have to be really good to be special for me like Okami and SMG did the last years;.