Argh, that list was terrible piece of shit.
He basically jumped on Harvest Moon (a great series), The Sims (not my type of game but I can see why its so good) and Nintendogs (never played it but I understand why its so successful) because he had no fucking idea that people like to play games that don't involve shooting aliens. (Who wants to carry out menial tasks on a farm? Me. Thats who.)
He ripped on Mario for not containing a storyline - since when has Mario contained a story line? Only the Paper Mario and Mario RPG have contained stories.
Fable is not one of the most detested games ever - it was overhyped but its still generally recognized as a solid, but not brilliant, game.