Every heavily praised game gets those types of comments. No matter how good something is, give it to 100 people and chances are 1 or 2 of them will feel differently to the general consensus of that group. They might not hate it, but they likewise might not think it's the greatest thing ever. Expand that to millions, and you end up with a lot of people feeling that way.
If TLOU2, RDR2, and SMO all get 90+ scores, they'll all get similar comments.








