By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
BasilZero said:
No one rated above a 8 for WM36 xD

I'm just really surprised it got that many 8s.  If you took the best matches from WM, you'd have a solid WWE PPV.  The problem is all the subpar stuff that surrounded it.  

I'm not proclaiming Dave Meltzer's ratings as gospel or anything but I think everything here falls in line with the general concensus, so I'm posting it to give a kind of overview:

NXT Takeover: Orlando

SAnitY vs. Tye/Ruby/Roddy/Hero 3.25

Black vs. Almas 3.25

AOP vs. DIY vs. Revival 4.5

Asuka vs. Moon 4.25

Roode vs. Nakamura 4.5

Wrestlemania 33

Neville vs. Aries 3.75

Andre Battle Royale 2

Ambrose vs. Corbin 2

Styles vs. Shane 4

Owens vs. Jericho 3.5

Bayley vs. Charlotte vs. Sasha vs. Nia 3.25

Hardyz vs. Club vs. Cesaro/Sheamus vs. Enzo/Cass 3.75

Bella/Cena vs. Miz/Maryse 2.25

Rollins vs. HHH 3.5

Orton vs. Wyatt 1.5

Lesnar vs. Goldberg 3.5

Naomi vs. Bliss vs. Carmella vs. Mickie vs. Natalya vs. Becky 1.5

Reigns vs. Taker 3

https://www.reddit.com/r/SquaredCircle/comments/63rfe9/meltzers_wrestlemania_33_and_takeover_orlando/

 

Pretty clear to me that, as a wrestling show, Takeover was better than Wrestlemania.  Some people really like all the auxillary stuff that comes with Wrestlemania, though, which is something I care nothing about.  I look at it as just another PPV.