By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
jonathanalis said:
which meta score would banjo kazooie receive if launched these days? I think that wouldnt be much different.

That's not a fair comparison though.  That game was made at the dawn of 3D gaming, this was made after 20 years of learning.  That would be like saying an X-Games gold metalist shouldn't be criticized for messing up a trick because you wouldn't be super hard on a kid who was just learning.  The fact that if Banjo Kazooie was repackaged and launched as something else would score like this is not a relevant.  It's an early 3D game, it was judged well by the standards of the time.  Yooka-Laylee, for all its nostalgia, is a 2017 game and should be expected to have learned some of the basic design lessons that last 20 years had to teach.