binary solo said:
JRPGfan said:
Persona 5... at 36 reviews and a 94 score :) hell yeah.
thejimquisition is the only reviewer to give it under 90 ; _ ; and he gave it a 85!
Why Jim... Why?
"Honestly, I only have one major gripe with Persona 5, and it’s a gripe that I’m not sure is unfair or not. A big part of my ability to invest as much time as I did into Persona 4 Golden was due to it being playable on the Vita, a portable system, and Persona 5 being locked to home consoles (PS3 and PS4) does somewhat hamper my ability to integrate it into my life. While I usually want to be playing the game’s big sprawling dungeons on a TV, the slow intricate social life management sections of Persona are honestly perfect fodder for playing on the sofa while watching TV or on a quick bus ride to pass the time."
8.5 / 10
>_< he scored it lower than he would have, because it wasnt portable? wtf.
|
If he derived a lot of satisfaction form the portable aspect why not downscore it for missing a feature he personally found to enhance his experience? I think it's a fair reason to know a few points off a game if it is an important element to the reviewer, especially since he's still giving it an 8.5. It's not like the too much water 6.5 debacle.
|
It's like saying "This game is on Xbox and my friends play on PS4 so I can't play with them, it sucks", it's not about the quality of the game...
