By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Cerebralbore on 29 March 2017
Edit Thread
LudicrousSpeed said:
Cerebralbore said:
I left Xbox out because it is generally agreed on these forums that MS doesn't have many exclusives.


And yet by your very own definition of what counts as a quality exclusive, Microsoft has provided 13 this gen and Sony has provided 11. And that's even including two games on your list that don't meet your own 80% metascore qualification, like LBP3 and RIGS. I could have included Halo Wars 2 which has the same 79% score LBP3 does but I didn't. Otherwise the count would be 14 vs 11 with Microsoft ahead :)

Cerebralbore said:

That's every AAA XB1 game rated 80% or higher that you can't play on PS4 from 2014 to 2017. I even threw Ori and the Blind Forest in there for good measure.


lol what do you mean "for good measure"? You're including remasters of PS3 games and games available on PS3/Vita in your PS4 list, why would you not include Ori on an Xbox list? You don't need to act as if you're throwing the Xbox a bone there, including Ori is simply following your own guidelines as to which games "count". And no, that's not every Xbone game you can't play on PS4.

Sunset (MS)
Master Chief Collection (MS)
Horizon 2 (MS)
Titanfall
Gears Ultimate (MS)
Halo 5 (MS)
Rare Replay (MS)
Ori (MS)
Forza 6 (MS)
Gears 4 (MS)
Killer Instinct Season 3 (MS)
Horizon 3 (MS)
Ori Definitive Edition (MS, I am including it because you're including remasters on your list)
Halo Wars Definitive Edition (MS)
Halo Wars 2 (MS, which I'll go ahead and count despite its 79 metascore since you included LBP3 and RIGS)

There's 14 games from MS there, which is more than your entire PC list, and more "exclusives that count" than Sony going by your own criteria via what you already posted. So you can say it's "generally agreed MS has no exclusives on this forum" but realize it's only because of FUD like your own list, chock full of bias and double standards and Game A counts on list 1 but Game B doesn't count on list 2 even though it fits the same criteria type of shenanigans.

So just remember next time you're thinking about how MS has no exclusives, that going by your very own standard you've already posted in this thread for us to see, they've actually outpaced Sony. I look forward to your response where you do more of this:

 

 

Yeah, you have a point as far as Master Chief Collection, and Gears Ultimate go. If I'm allowing remasters  of Vita games then you should be able to allow remasters of 360 games. Gears Ultimate, Gears 4, and Forza Horizon 3 should all be counted towards PC's games that can't be played on PS4. That brings PC's number versus PS4 up to 13 games. Since remasters count, let's be fair and say that TLoU Remastered counts too.

Halo Wars doesn't have 10 reviews on either gamerankings or metacritic, so it didn't meet my criteria. RIGs and LBP both have 80% or higher, and Halo Wars 2 does not. Killer Instinct season 3 is not a game, but DLC to a game, so it doesn't meet my criteria either.

There's 14 games from MS there, which is more than your entire PC list,

Titanfall, Gears Ultimate, Gears 4, Killer Instinct, Forza Horizon 3 and Ori are all on PC. If you count Arkham Knight XB1 has 7 games that are not on PC, that meet my criteria.

and more "exclusives that count" than Sony going by your own criteria via what you already posted.

That would be 12 high rated XB1 games that can't be played on PS4. Meanwhile PS4 has 18 high rated games that can't be played on XB1. Honestly counting Forza (which releases every year), is about as silly as counting MLB the Show (Which also releases every year), but I'll allow it. In case you were wondering, I'm not counting the MLB games towards my PS4 numbers. Edit: Why are we counting Rare Replay? That would be like counting PS1 games on the PSN store.