By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
thismeintiel said:
LudicrousSpeed said:

Riiiiiiight. Gonna need to see a reliable source on that with some real data. At least 33%? Uh, no. And it's not as if Sony has been innocent of faulty hardware. DRE was common on PS2 and there was the YLOD last gen. Sure, compared to early gen 360 models it looks better but compared to other console companies like Nintendo or Sega, they don't.

Squaretrade, a big warranty provider, calculated it at 24% percent. Of course, considering MS was basically forced by public opinion to provide replacements/repairs free of charge, Squaretrade didn't see a lot of those. Game Informer calculated it at 54% based on a survey of 1000s. So, the real number is somewhere in between.  Game Informer calculated the PS3 at 10%, so the real number is probably lower. Again, inferior reliability.

I obviously can't provide the actual failure rate of the 360 in a worldwide context, but I can reliably relate the failure rate of my 360s, which was 80%. Every single non-S 360 I owned died, including a launch console that died so quickly that MS had yet to institute the extended warranties, and that the customer service kindly suggested that I had caused to red ring, even though I give my consoles space and still have a working SNES, N64, ps2, Genesis and launch ps3. I know stories like mine aren't the be all end all, and there are likely more fortunate people who never had a 360 die, but all 4 of the 360s I either bought or received as a replacement for a faulty system red ringed. The 4 gb S I eventually bought still works just fine, however.