The problem with my #1 is that it cycles through the few games that I truly feel like they all deserve that spot. So depending on my mood, the day you ask me or what I'm itching to play it might change on the spot, though those cycle of games have remained almost unchanged for some years now, with the only change of The Talos Principle being added in 2015.
I'm pretty indecise to put just one above the rest. I think it's just that I make a re-evaluation everytime the question is asked, because of several factors. This being said, I played both Final Fantasy VIII and The curse of Monkey Island as a kid and they still remain in that cycle of mine to this day, so they deserve especial mention. But even between these two I wouldn't know which one to pick.
