No Horizon on this? It's still a potential contender for the top 5. We know almost nothing about RDR2 and Mass Effect: Andromeda isn't out yet, so it's hard to say.
I think Breath of the Wild will win this in the end though. If it loses to something with a lesser reception, then the VGA's will be taken into question. A lot of people seemed to disagree with the last couple of years. Overwatch was great, but winning over Uncharted 4? I don't know, Uncharted 4 achieved so much where Overwatch was Blizzard's twist on the TF2 gametype with crazy mechanics. It was fun but it didn't blow my mind like Uncharted 4 did. Still a good game but that's just me. I also felt that MGSV: The Phantom Pain deserved to win over 2015. I thought it was waaay better than The Witcher 3. Though I suppose that one is far more subjective. I just thought TPP was all around better.
