Uncharted 1+2 and The Last of Us.
Maybe if they were on PC with Mouse/keyboard controls I might have liked them, but the combat was awful with dual analog controls, and I got bored of it and the rest of the gameplay after a short while each time I tried them.
Metroid Prime on Gamecube.
Again an issue of controls. The trilogy edition on Wii was so much more enjoyable. ut it probably also didn't help that I was a little kid when I tried Prime for the first time and got really frustrated fighting this one giant plant boss over and over again. That boss is pretty easy now.