This is a tough round yo... this is how i judged it:
5p - cirio - Clean cut handsomeness.
4p - goodnightmoon - Just chill and mysterious. Would like to see some eyes though.
3p - think-man - Draws you in with his enchanting looks. Instrument helps a bit. Without it, probably would think he was high.
2p - TheBlackNaruto - Looks very sophisticated.
1p - Swordf1sh - Mature and rugged.