They all have pros and cons.
The GamePad has a lot of neat features but the L/ZL and R/ZR triggers/bumpers are super awkward.
The DS4 is a big improvement over DS3, but the stick placement is so uncomfortable. I shouldn't have to contort to play a game.
Pro Controller has great battery life but it's a little on the simplistic side.
XOne controller has the asymmetrical sticks I love plus a good grip and triggers. D-pad and bumpers are just ok.
So I'd rank them
4) GamePad
3) DS4
2) WiiU pro
1) XOne










