By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Nice idea. So TLG takes the first spot. It's been years since a not-Nintendo title is my personal GOTY. But, tbh, Nintendo's 2016 was awful. TLG was one of the most beautiful, emotional experiences I've had in gaming. Despite of some control issues, it's an awesome game.

2nd would probably be Overwatch, so it's nice to see some Overwatch love in this thread. Also, ROTR (technically a 2015 game but still...), Uncharted 4 and Pokemon were also highlights.