The Xbox Rant - MS needs to step up their game

[FunFan]

DonFerrari said:

FunFan said:

By that logic then the PS4 is also a disappointment as the PS3/360 still has the better library in most genres in terms of quality, variety and even sales, if you include all "playable" games. Don't get me wrong, I completely agree with this. But isn't it logical to compare the XBOne with the PS4? I mean if we start counting last gen games the XBOne has better backwards compatibility so it's not going to be pretty...

When you say a game or a series is DOMINATING the genre then you have to consider all possible contenders. Like when I say that even on the worse selling GT game no competitor outsell it there will always be someone saying Mario Kart, I usually excludes it because I barely consider it even a racer much less when I'm talking about GT (competitors would be games like FM, Project Cars, Assetto Corza, etc... and if we push it NFS, FH, Burnout, etc).

If we are talking about PS4 vs X1 only then X1 considering all racing games available is in a better position than PS4 (although I really like DC) but can't be said that Forza alone is dominating the genre even if we consider only both platforms.

Thats the thing, I didn't said that. You are puting words in my mouth. Look back at my original response. I said "Xbone is dominating", I didn't mentioned forza at all.