Depends on the game.
So as an example, lets say its a new IP that has single player story, coop and online. I will deduct marks if the single player is lousy even if the online excellent since if there is a single player story mode, then it better be good.
Lets take another example. Lets say a new IP has a single player mode that is basically just tracks/missions without an actual story or much focus on one but it has an excellent online. I would deduct marks but since they aren't focusing on the single player very much, I wouldn't deduct them as harshly because they are selling the game for its online provided they advertise as such.
And lets do a final example. Lets say it is an old IP like MK but a new iteration but the new iteration doesn't have something that is as good or better than the previous iteration such as battlemode. I will 110% deduct marks because a new iteration has to be at a minimum the same level of quality as the previous version and then it must have new shitz.
Thats what I would do anyway
PC Specs: CPU: 7800X3D || GPU: Strix 4090 || RAM: 32GB DDR5 6000 || Main SSD: WD 2TB SN850







