your controversial opinion about "one of the best games ever made"

[Super_Boom]

My favorite game ever is Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, which not only sold poorly, but is part of a genre that isn't known for amazing meta-scores.

If we're talking about other people's favorite games, I have a tough time enjoying the Uncharted games. The story and graphics are amazing, and I enjoy the parkour elements...but the gunplay has never felt very fun to me.

Probably not as controversial, but though I loved Persona 4, there are games in its own frachise I enjoyed much more.