By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
AbbathTheGrim said:
I would ask this god, since you are all-powerful and supposedly can do anything, can you make a stone so heavy that not even you can lift? Can you do it or not?

I would ask him, do we really have freewill? If so, did Judas have true freewill? If he really had freewill it means there was a chance he wouldn't betray Jesus and his crucifixion would not go through, meaning your god's will not always go through.

I would ask him, if you god know it all, how much of a choice did Judas have when he, like Adam and Eve, were given a test by a god who knew all along how they would act in front of what this god put before them.

These are, I am sure that you know, the cornerstone questions from rational atheism. I would prefer if you had choose to answer in a more direct way, as Chris Hitchens did. He also use these two famous questions in every debate he did till he died.

But I take your answer is: My belief in a non-theistic reality is so rock solid that I can´t even imagine a answer to such a question.



My grammar errors are justified by the fact that I am a brazilian living in Brazil. I am also very stupid.